Mechanic’s Liens vs. Lawsuits: Weighing Options for Payment Disputes

When payment disputes arise in construction and contracting, seeking compensation can be complex. Two common avenues to resolve these issues are mechanic's liens and traditional lawsuits. This blog will delve into the pros and cons of mechanic's liens and lawsuits to help you make informed decisions when navigating payment disputes.

Understanding Mechanic’s Liens

Following the significant disruptions caused by the COVID-19 pandemic in the construction industry, there has been a 40% increase in mechanic’s liens. A mechanic's lien is a legal claim placed on a property by a contractor, subcontractor, or supplier who has provided labor or materials but has yet to receive payment. The lien serves as security against the property until the owed amount is settled. Now, let's break down the advantages and disadvantages of using mechanic's liens:

Pros of Mechanic's Liens:

  • Strong Legal Position: Mechanic's liens grant contractors a powerful legal tool to secure payment. They can enforce the lien by potentially forcing the sale of the property to satisfy the debt.
  • Cost-Efficient: Filing a mechanic's lien is generally less expensive than pursuing a lawsuit. It allows you to claim what's rightfully owed without requiring extensive legal fees.
  • Preservation of Cash Flow: A mechanic's lien can act as leverage, incentivizing property owners and developers to address payment disputes promptly to avoid any complications with property transactions.

Cons of Mechanic's Liens:

  • Limited to Property Value: The amount recoverable through a mechanic's lien is often limited to the property's value. You may not receive full compensation if the property's value is insufficient to cover the debt.
  • Property Sale Uncertainty: Enforcing a mechanic's lien can be lengthy, and the property may not sell immediately. This can delay your receipt of payment.
  • Legal Complexities: Navigating mechanic's lien laws and procedures can be intricate, requiring strict adherence to specific timelines and documentation.

Understanding Lawsuits

In contrast to mechanic's liens, traditional lawsuits involve taking legal action against the party in a dispute to recover unpaid amounts. Here are the key advantages and disadvantages:

Pros of Lawsuits:

  • No Property Limitation: Lawsuits are not bound by property value restrictions, potentially allowing you to seek compensation beyond the property's worth.
  • Legal Resolution: Lawsuits provide a formal and structured legal process that can lead to a judgment in your favor. You can then pursue various means to collect the owed amount.
  • Discovery and Evidence: Lawsuits enable thorough examination of evidence, including depositions, documents, and testimonies, which can strengthen your case.

Cons of Lawsuits:

  • Higher Costs: Traditional lawsuits can be expensive, involving attorney fees, court costs, and potentially a lengthy legal process. This can impact your overall recovery.
  • Time-Consuming: Lawsuits typically take longer to resolve than mechanic's liens, delaying your ability to collect payment.
  • No Guaranteed Outcome: Despite the expenses and time invested, there's no guarantee of a favorable judgment, and collecting from a reluctant debtor can be challenging.

Choosing the Right Path for Your Payment Dispute

Deciding between mechanic's liens and lawsuits hinges on various factors, including the specific circumstances of your case, the amount in dispute, and your overall objectives. Here are some considerations to guide your choice:

  • Amount in Dispute: Mechanic's liens may offer a cost-effective and efficient solution for more minor claims. A lawsuit might be more appropriate for larger disputes due to its broader recovery potential.
  • Property Value: Evaluate whether the property in question holds sufficient value to cover your debt. If not, a lawsuit may be a better option.
  • Timeline: Consider your urgency for payment. Mechanic's Liens can prompt quicker responses, while lawsuits may entail more extended legal proceedings.
  • Legal Counsel: Consult with an attorney specializing in construction law to assess the specifics of your situation and receive tailored advice.

Whether you opt for the strategic power of mechanic's liens or the structured approach of a lawsuit, the choice should be driven by the unique circumstances of your payment dispute. Regardless of your path, seeking legal guidance is essential when navigating the intricate terrain of construction payment disputes. With Catalyst Legal as your legal partner, you can protect your interests and secure the payments you deserve, utilizing mechanic's liens to your advantage.


Get In Touch

We will be in touch shortly to see how we can assist your business with their legal needs.